| # | Player | Comments |
| 1 | Bob Probert | The Number 1 of all time. Bar None |
| 2 | Joey Kocur | The right hand of cement. Devestating puncher, anyone who hates this guy is either and idiot or a Devils fan |
| 3 | Sandy McCarthy | Monster of a man that had some great battles with many of the legends |
| 4 | Tie Domi | Toughest little bastard with balls of steel |
| 5 | Craig Berube | One of the fastest hands around. Great fighter that threw with abandon |
| 6 | John Kordic | How can anyone not like this guy. Half crazy, half nuts |
| 7 | Darren Langdon | One of the best technical fighters to ever play. Throws with both hands and could tie up anyone and wear them out |
| 8 | Shane Churla | The guy had the heart of a lion. Tough as nails and a great teammate |
| 9 | Stu Grimson | Possibly the scarriest man to ever play |
| 10 | Jim McKenzie | Big Jim. Underated. He was big and powerful and rarely looked bad when he lost |
| 11 | Marty McSorley | Stanima is unmatched. Throws with both hands fought pretty much every legend out there and won most. Top five all time |
| 12 | Ken Baumgartner | Very underated. Great technical fighter. The Bomber could switch hands with the best of them |
| 13 | Adam Graves | The ultimate Teammate. Did not fight a whole lot but when he did it was usually coming to a teammates defense. |
| 14 | Jay Wells | The Old Dog is another very underated fighter who has beat some legends in his time. Good defenseman that was tough as can be. |
| 15 | Peter Worrell | One big Motherf'er. If this guy had power like Kocur or Twist people would have died. Most of his fights ended by Big Pete tagging the guy and the guy burying his head in Worrells chest. A Monster |
| 16 | Chris Nilan | Love this man. One tough SOB. Another balls of steel guy. Great, Great fighter on my top twenty list |
| 17 | Colton Orr | Becoming a favorite. He may lose some but he is entertaining and may have the most devestating punch since Kocur. He will only get better. Could be a future champ |
| 18 | P.J. Stock | holy shit is the only way to describe this guy. The ultimate put the head down and throw guy. You have to love tough little guys like him |
| 19 | Chris Simon | Big powerful lefty that does not lose very often at all. He is a monster and very good fighter. Top 25 no doubt |
| 20 | Rick Tocchet | Hate the flyers. Love Tocchet. One of the toughest and best all around wingers to ever lace them up |
| 21 | Jason Strudwick | How can you not like him. Always, Always sticks up for his teammates and is a very underrated fighter |