| # | Player | Comments |
| 1 | Wendel Clark | Prototypical power forward. Was pound for pound the best fighter the league has ever seen. Deadly wrist shot, a wicked slap shot and bone crushing hits that put players out of action. Could throw with both hands very effectively and ended many fights REAL quick. My favourite player of all time. |
| 2 | Joey Kocur | Hardest punch bar none!!! Good Saskatchewan boy who would take 3 punches to give you one of his haymakers. Would grab a fistful of ice everytime he threw a punch. |
| 3 | Wayne Gretzky | Greatest player to ever play. Wasn't the fastest, didn't have the hardest shot and never played physical. Scored some unbeleivable goals and made the other team look stupid. He is as proficient a point getter as anyone in any sport. No one else has dominated hockey like Gretzky. |
| 4 | Chris Nilan | Good 80's fighter, wrestled a little but was fun to watch. |
| 5 | Bob Probert | Have you seen anyone tougher in the NHL before or since, I don't think so! |
| 6 | Shayne Corson | Good player, smart fighter and was double tough. |
| 7 | Tie Domi | Very good for his size, knew his role and did his job well. Could hit him over the head with a sledgehammer and he wouldn't feel it. |
| 8 | Georges Laraque | Strong and is a lefty. Very professional, plays decent minutes for an enforcer. |
| 9 | Cam Neely | Imagine what the NHL would be like today if every team had one of him. Didn't have fancy moves but knew how to find the net. |
| 10 | Jordin Tootoo | One of the most exciting players to watch as far as playing hard and finishing checkers. Great open ice hitter and a solid fighter who can throw with both. |
| 11 | Brad May | I never liked Buffalo, but he was a straight shooter and could throw very good with both hands. Certainly the toughest out of Ray, Barnaby and Boughner. |
| 12 | Mike Bossy | A magician with the puck, never let his stick go over his shoulders and could pick apart goalies with ease. |
| 13 | Chris Chelios | One of the best defencemen in the last 20 years. I can't say he's not cheap or a threatening fighter, but he is tough, not fighting tough, punishment tough. |
| 14 | Tony Twist | 18" Biceps, capped shoulders, traps and a deadly right hand. |