| # | Player | Comments |
| 1 | Chris Nilan | |
| 2 | Riley Cote | Most overrated fighter, maybe ever. Speedbag Cote. |
| 3 | Tie Domi | |
| 4 | Georges Laraque | Rabbit puncher. |
| 5 | Jordin Tootoo | Cheap-shot. Tough, but has never fought an actual tough-guy. |
| 6 | Donald Brashear | Tough as all hell, no question. But ever since i saw that video of him destroying that dude while he was down on the ice i've hated him. Saw him get knocked out by Belak the other day.. that was nice. I like watching the McSorley clip too, just for kicks. |
| 7 | Derek Boogaard | |
| 8 | Claude Lemieux | Make that 101 people that hate him. |
| 9 | Sean Avery | Possibly the most hated on this site. He's a decent hockey player tho. But i cant repesct his game... unless he was on my team, then i would probably get over it- he's that type of player. |