| Sep 18, 1995 Mon | Preseason | Toronto | Ottawa | Domi-Vial (6.4) |
| Sep 19, 1995 Tue | Preseason | Detroit | Toronto | McCarty-Baumgartner Pushor-Domi (5.8) (Rough) Hankinson-Warriner Grimson-Momesso (7) (Rough) Taylor-Ellett Grimson-Domi (5.8) McCarty-Baumgartner (8) |
| Sep 20, 1995 Wed | Preseason | Toronto | Buffalo | Rychel-Barnaby (8) Gill-Ray (7.5) |
| Sep 22, 1995 Fri | Preseason | Montreal | Toronto | Add Fight |
| Sep 23, 1995 Sat | Preseason | Toronto | Montreal | Rychel-Keane (8) Domi-Brashear (6.6) Warriner-Malakhov (Rough) Rychel-Stevenson |
| Sep 27, 1995 Wed | Preseason | Colorado | Toronto | Add Fight |
| Sep 28, 1995 Thu | Preseason | Toronto | Colorado | (Cheap) Jonsson-Schulte Baumgartner-Schulte |
| Sep 29, 1995 Fri | Preseason | Toronto | Detroit | Add Fight |
| Oct 2, 1995 Mon | Preseason | Buffalo | Toronto | Add Fight |
| Oct 7, 1995 Sat | | Toronto | Pittsburgh | (Hit) Gill-Nedved |
| Oct 10, 1995 Tue | | NY Islanders | Toronto | (Hit) Palffy-Yushkevich (4) Severyn-Domi (3.8) Vukota-Domi (4.5) (Cheap) Lindros-Gill (4) McCabe-Hogue (5) |
| Oct 14, 1995 Sat | | NY Rangers | Toronto | (Cheap) Presley-Gilmour Presley-Gill (3) Samuelsson-Domi (9.6) |
| Oct 17, 1995 Tue | | San Jose | Toronto | (Hit) Peltonen-Yushkevich Odgers-Baumgartner (5.8) |
| Oct 20, 1995 Fri | | Calgary | Toronto | Add Fight |
| Oct 21, 1995 Sat | | Toronto | Montreal | Baumgartner-Odelein (2) |
| Oct 24, 1995 Tue | | Florida | Toronto | (Cheap) Lowry-Hendrickson Laus-Baumgartner (2.7) Warrener-Hudson (6) |
| Oct 26, 1995 Thu | | Toronto | Chicago | (Cheap) Berg-Ulanov Zettler-Probert (4.7) Berg-Ulanov (4) |
| Oct 28, 1995 Sat | | Los Angeles | Toronto | Scrum at 29:00 (Cheap) Petit-unknown |
| Oct 29, 1995 Sun | | Toronto | NY Rangers | Add Fight |
| Nov 1, 1995 Wed | | Toronto | Winnipeg | Baumgartner-McKenzie (7) |
| Nov 3, 1995 Fri | | Toronto | Vancouver | Domi-Odjick (6.2) (Hit) Domi-Courtnall (4) |
| Nov 4, 1995 Sat | | Toronto | Edmonton | Domi-Bonvie (6.2) Scrum at 34:47 |
| Nov 7, 1995 Tue | | Anaheim | Toronto | Ewen-Baumgartner (4) |
| Nov 10, 1995 Fri | | Washington | Toronto | Kaminski-Domi (3) |
| Nov 11, 1995 Sat | | Toronto | Boston | Add Fight |
| Nov 14, 1995 Tue | | Toronto | Florida | Add Fight |
| Nov 16, 1995 Thu | | Toronto | Tampa Bay | Add Fight |
| Nov 18, 1995 Sat | | Winnipeg | Toronto | Add Fight |
| Nov 21, 1995 Tue | | St. Louis | Toronto | Chasse-Baumgartner (5.5) |
| Nov 24, 1995 Fri | | Hartford | Toronto | Add Fight |
| Nov 25, 1995 Sat | | Toronto | St. Louis | Baumgartner-Twist (3.4) |
| Nov 28, 1995 Tue | | Toronto | Winnipeg | Add Fight |
| Nov 30, 1995 Thu | | Toronto | Philadelphia | (Hit) Craig-Svoboda |
| Dec 2, 1995 Sat | | Anaheim | Toronto | Lambert-Baumgartner (3.5) |
| Dec 5, 1995 Tue | | Ottawa | Toronto | Add Fight |
| Dec 7, 1995 Thu | | Toronto | New Jersey | Baumgartner-Hulse (6.5) Ellett-Zelepukin (3) |
| Dec 9, 1995 Sat | | Dallas | Toronto | (Cheap) Harvey-Jonsson Harvey-Hogue (8) |
| Dec 11, 1995 Mon | | Colorado | Toronto | (Rough) Simon-Domi (4) Simon-Domi (8.2) |
| Dec 14, 1995 Thu | | Toronto | San Jose | Baumgartner-Odgers (5) Gill-Nazarov (4) |
| Dec 16, 1995 Sat | | Toronto | Los Angeles | (Hit) Domi-McSorley (2) Domi-McSorley (2.4) |
| Dec 17, 1995 Sun | | Toronto | Anaheim | Domi-Karpa (3.3) Gill-Hicks (5.7) |
| Dec 20, 1995 Wed | | Chicago | Toronto | (Cheap) Russell-Baumgartner (5) Russell-Baumgartner (7) |
| Dec 21, 1995 Thu | | Toronto | Chicago | Wood-Chelios (2) Mini-Brawl at 17:35 (Rough) Wood-Roenick (Rough) Hendrickson-Amonte (Rough) Gilmour-Belfour Scrum at 36:20 (Rough) Domi-Belfour (4) |
| Dec 23, 1995 Sat | | Edmonton | Toronto | Event |
| Dec 27, 1995 Wed | | Toronto | Calgary | Add Fight |
| Dec 29, 1995 Fri | | Toronto | Colorado | Add Fight |
| Dec 30, 1995 Sat | | Toronto | St. Louis | Add Fight |
| Jan 1, 1996 Mon | | Toronto | Dallas | (Cheap) Zettler-Nieuwendyk (Hit) Domi-Churla (3) (Rough) Wood-Lalor |
| Jan 3, 1996 Wed | | Boston | Toronto | (Hit) Zombo-Gilmour |
| Jan 5, 1996 Fri | | Toronto | Buffalo | (Rough) Momesso-Barnaby (3) Domi-Ray (8.8) Scrum at 17:48 (5) (Cheap) DiPietro-Hughes (4) Scrum at 46:03 (3) Domi-Houda (3) Scrum at 52:19 (3) Crowd Trouble at 52:19 (7) |
| Jan 6, 1996 Sat | | Colorado | Toronto | Simon-Domi (8) |
| Jan 10, 1996 Wed | | Los Angeles | Toronto | (Hit) Slaney-Domi (6) Potomski-Baumgartner (3.5) |
| Jan 11, 1996 Thu | | Toronto | NY Islanders | (Cheap) Berg-Schneider |
| Jan 13, 1996 Sat | | Vancouver | Toronto | Malkoc-Baumgartner (7.6) Malkoc-Gill (6) |
| Jan 17, 1996 Wed | | Winnipeg | Toronto | Add Fight |
| Jan 24, 1996 Wed | | Chicago | Toronto | Probert-Domi (4.1) (Refused) Probert-Domi (3) (Refused) Probert-Domi (3) (Refused) Cummins-Domi (3) Cummins-Baumgartner (7) (Rough) Probert-Domi (5) (Cheap) Belfour-Domi (3) (Rough) Chelios-Berg |
| Jan 27, 1996 Sat | | Toronto | Ottawa | Domi-Vial (6.8) |
| Jan 30, 1996 Tue | | Toronto | Detroit | (Hit) Jonsson-Fedorov |
| Jan 31, 1996 Wed | | St. Louis | Toronto | Pearson-Muller (6.5) |
| Feb 3, 1996 Sat | | Montreal | Toronto | Brashear-Domi (4.3) (Refused) Brashear-Domi (3) |
| Feb 5, 1996 Mon | | Toronto | San Jose | Add Fight |
| Feb 7, 1996 Wed | | Toronto | Anaheim | Baumgartner-Ewen (3) |
| Feb 8, 1996 Thu | | Toronto | Los Angeles | Add Fight |
| Feb 10, 1996 Sat | | Buffalo | Toronto | Ray-Domi (5.5) Ray-Domi (7) Barnaby-Muller (7.8) May-Baumgartner (8.8) Scrum at 20:44 Scrum at 45:00 (6) |
| Feb 12, 1996 Mon | | Pittsburgh | Toronto | (Hit) Nedved-Zettler (Hit) Tamer-Warriner (Rough) Wilkinson-Gilmour Scrum at 51:52 Leroux-Domi (5.8) Scrum at 57:05 Moran-Hendrickson (8) |
| Feb 14, 1996 Wed | | San Jose | Toronto | Add Fight |
| Feb 16, 1996 Fri | | Toronto | Washington | Add Fight |
| Feb 18, 1996 Sun | | Detroit | Toronto | (Refused) Primeau-Domi (3) (Cheap) Fedorov-Domi (4) (Almost) Grimson-Baumgartner Errey-Gilmour Grimson-Baumgartner (5.2) |
| Feb 21, 1996 Wed | | Tampa Bay | Toronto | Wiemer-Gill (8.3) Ciccone-Momesso (6) |
| Feb 22, 1996 Thu | | Toronto | Detroit | Muller-Lapointe (7) Domi-Grimson (7.7) |
| Feb 24, 1996 Sat | | Dallas | Toronto | Add Fight |
| Feb 28, 1996 Wed | | Toronto | Winnipeg | (Hit) Muller-Tkachuk Baumgartner-McKenzie (3.3) Domi-Manson (1.7) |
| Mar 2, 1996 Sat | | Toronto | Dallas | Kypreos-Huard (6) (Rough) Domi-bench (4) |
| Mar 3, 1996 Sun | | Toronto | Colorado | (Hit) Kypreos-Ricci (2) (Rough) Domi-Simon (4) Domi-Simon (7.9) |
| Mar 6, 1996 Wed | | New Jersey | Toronto | Simpson-Domi (7.8) (Rough) Smith-Domi (2.5) |
| Mar 8, 1996 Fri | | Toronto | Hartford | Domi-Daniels (4.5) (Rough) Ellett-Nikolishin Presley-Janssens |
| Mar 9, 1996 Sat | | Calgary | Toronto | Roberts-Sundin (5.3) Bench-Clearing Brawl at 60:00 (9) |
| Mar 13, 1996 Wed | | Winnipeg | Toronto | King-Gill (7) |
| Mar 15, 1996 Fri | | Dallas | Toronto | Event at 0:00 (Cheap) Hatcher-Gagner Scrum at 14:55 (6) Marshall-Domi (1) Line Brawl at 20:00 (5) Sydor-Gill (7) Huard-Domi (7.3) |
| Mar 17, 1996 Sun | | Vancouver | Toronto | Malkoc-Kypreos (3) |
| Mar 19, 1996 Tue | | Toronto | Detroit | Add Fight |
| Mar 20, 1996 Wed | | Detroit | Toronto | Primeau-Muller (4.4) (Rough) Coffey-Gartner (3) (Rough) Primeau-Domi (4) (Rough) Coffey-Presley (3) |
| Mar 23, 1996 Sat | | Philadelphia | Toronto | Scrum at 41:00 (3.5) (Cheap) Brind'Amour-Domi (6) |
| Mar 25, 1996 Mon | | Toronto | Calgary | Add Fight |
| Mar 27, 1996 Wed | | Toronto | Vancouver | Add Fight |
| Mar 30, 1996 Sat | | Toronto | Edmonton | (Hit) Gagner-Mironov (5) (Cheap) Kypreos-Marchment (4) (Rough) Domi-Marchment (4) |
| Apr 3, 1996 Wed | | Chicago | Toronto | Probert-Domi (7.5) (Refused) Probert-Domi (3) |
| Apr 4, 1996 Thu | | Toronto | St. Louis | (Hit) Yushkevich-Courtnall (3) Event at 24:01 |
| Apr 6, 1996 Sat | | St. Louis | Toronto | Add Fight |
| Apr 11, 1996 Thu | | Toronto | Chicago | (Cheap) Kypreos-Cummins (8) (Rough) Presley-Cummins (3) Kypreos-Russell (6.8) (Rough) Gagner-Ciccone Domi-Probert (5.2) (Almost) Kypreos-Cummins Kypreos-Cummins (7.8) Domi-Ciccone (2.8) (Refused) Domi-Probert (3) |
| Apr 13, 1996 Sat | | Edmonton | Toronto | (Rough) Mironov-Gagner (3) (Rough) Buchberger-Domi (3) |
| Apr 16, 1996 Tue | Round 1 | Game 1 | St. Louis | Toronto | Add Fight |
| Apr 18, 1996 Thu | Round 1 | Game 2 | St. Louis | Toronto | (Hit) Hull-Clark (3) (Cheap) Fuhr-Kypreos (8) (Cheap) Baron-Kypreos (5) (Rough) Twist-Kypreos (4) (Rough) Hull-Gilmour (4) (Rough) Creighton-Domi (4) |
| Apr 21, 1996 Sun | Round 1 | Game 3 | Toronto | St. Louis | Add Fight |
| Apr 23, 1996 Tue | Round 1 | Game 4 | Toronto | St. Louis | (Rough) Domi-Matteau (3) |
| Apr 25, 1996 Thu | Round 1 | Game 5 | St. Louis | Toronto | Collision at 59:44 |
| Apr 27, 1996 Sat | Round 1 | Game 6 | Toronto | St. Louis | Add Fight |