| Sep 21, 1984 Fri | Preseason | NY Islanders | NY Rangers | Add Fight |
| Sep 23, 1984 Sun | Preseason | NY Islanders | NY Rangers | Add Fight |
| Sep 25, 1984 Tue | Preseason | NY Rangers | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Sep 28, 1984 Fri | Preseason | NY Islanders | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Sep 29, 1984 Sat | Preseason | Boston | NY Islanders | Hillier-Kerr
Hillier-Kerr
Milbury-Gillies |
| Oct 3, 1984 Wed | Preseason | Philadelphia | NY Islanders | Stothers-Hallin
Tocchet-Diduck
Tocchet-MacPherson
Stanley-Persson |
| Oct 4, 1984 Thu | Preseason | NY Islanders | Philadelphia | Add Fight |
| Oct 5, 1984 Fri | Preseason | Boston | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Oct 7, 1984 Sun | Preseason | Buffalo | NY Islanders | Ruff-Dineen |
| Oct 12, 1984 Fri | | NY Islanders | New Jersey | (Rough) Bourne-Gagne |
| Oct 13, 1984 Sat | | Chicago | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Oct 16, 1984 Tue | | New Jersey | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Oct 17, 1984 Wed | | NY Islanders | Detroit | Boutilier-Lambert (7) |
| Oct 20, 1984 Sat | | Los Angeles | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Oct 21, 1984 Sun | | NY Islanders | NY Rangers | Add Fight |
| Oct 23, 1984 Tue | | Vancouver | NY Islanders | (Hit) Neely-Potvin |
| Oct 27, 1984 Sat | | Boston | NY Islanders | Blum-Tonelli
Milbury-Dineen (7) |
| Oct 30, 1984 Tue | | NY Rangers | NY Islanders | McPhee-Flatley (2)
Patrick-Sutter |
| Nov 1, 1984 Thu | | NY Islanders | Montreal | Add Fight |
| Nov 3, 1984 Sat | | NY Islanders | Quebec | Add Fight |
| Nov 4, 1984 Sun | | NY Islanders | Boston | Add Fight |
| Nov 6, 1984 Tue | | St. Louis | NY Islanders | Sutter-Lane (2)
Schofield-Diduck |
| Nov 9, 1984 Fri | | NY Islanders | NY Rangers | Langevin-McPhee (6.7)
Tonelli-Sandstrom |
| Nov 10, 1984 Sat | | Pittsburgh | NY Islanders | Babych-Lane
Scrum at 42:55 |
| Nov 15, 1984 Thu | | Minnesota | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Nov 17, 1984 Sat | | NY Rangers | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Nov 18, 1984 Sun | | NY Islanders | Philadelphia | Add Fight |
| Nov 20, 1984 Tue | | Washington | NY Islanders | (Hit) Carpenter-Lane |
| Nov 23, 1984 Fri | | NY Islanders | Washington | Add Fight |
| Nov 24, 1984 Sat | | Buffalo | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Nov 28, 1984 Wed | | NY Islanders | Calgary | Add Fight |
| Nov 30, 1984 Fri | | NY Islanders | Winnipeg | Add Fight |
| Dec 3, 1984 Mon | | NY Islanders | Vancouver | Hallin-Butcher (5) |
| Dec 5, 1984 Wed | | NY Islanders | Edmonton | Hallin-Hughes (2) |
| Dec 8, 1984 Sat | | Hartford | NY Islanders | (Rough) Lumley-Bourne
Lumley-Sutter |
| Dec 11, 1984 Tue | | New Jersey | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Dec 12, 1984 Wed | | NY Islanders | Pittsburgh | (Rough) Potvin-Bullard
Diduck-Young (7) |
| Dec 15, 1984 Sat | | Philadelphia | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Dec 18, 1984 Tue | | Winnipeg | NY Islanders | Carlyle-Sutter |
| Dec 21, 1984 Fri | | NY Islanders | Hartford | Add Fight |
| Dec 22, 1984 Sat | | Pittsburgh | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Dec 26, 1984 Wed | | NY Islanders | Pittsburgh | Lane-Taylor (5)
Boutilier-Belanger
Sutter-Bodger |
| Dec 27, 1984 Thu | | Washington | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Dec 29, 1984 Sat | | NY Islanders | St. Louis | Add Fight |
| Dec 31, 1984 Mon | | NY Islanders | Minnesota | Diduck-Payne (2) |
| Jan 2, 1985 Wed | | NY Islanders | Detroit | Flatley-Aubry |
| Jan 5, 1985 Sat | | Buffalo | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Jan 8, 1985 Tue | | Montreal | NY Islanders | Carlson-Lane (5)
Nilan-Lane (5)
Carlson-Hallin (3) |
| Jan 10, 1985 Thu | | NY Islanders | New Jersey | Boutilier-Ludvig
(Rough) Sutter-Verbeek
Flatley-Hiemer |
| Jan 12, 1985 Sat | | Philadelphia | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Jan 13, 1985 Sun | | NY Islanders | Chicago | (Cheap) Smith-Fraser
Kerr-Bergevin (5)
Sutter-Wilson (3.4)
Dineen-Olczyk |
| Jan 15, 1985 Tue | | NY Islanders | Vancouver | Hallin-Neely (6.3) |
| Jan 16, 1985 Wed | | NY Islanders | Edmonton | Add Fight |
| Jan 19, 1985 Sat | | NY Islanders | Los Angeles | Hallin-Hardy
Gilbert-Ruskowski |
| Jan 22, 1985 Tue | | Detroit | NY Islanders | Campbell-Kerr
Lambert-Hallin |
| Jan 24, 1985 Thu | | Toronto | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Jan 26, 1985 Sat | | Washington | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Jan 27, 1985 Sun | | NY Islanders | Washington | (Cheap) Tonelli-Murphy (0) |
| Jan 29, 1985 Tue | | Minnesota | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Feb 1, 1985 Fri | | NY Islanders | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Feb 2, 1985 Sat | | NY Islanders | Pittsburgh | Boutilier-Belanger
(Rough) Gilbert-Loney |
| Feb 5, 1985 Tue | | Philadelphia | NY Islanders | Carson-Nystrom (5.6) |
| Feb 7, 1985 Thu | | NY Rangers | NY Islanders | McPhee-Nystrom (7.4)
(Rough) Beck-Sutter
(Rough) Ftorek-Diduck |
| Feb 9, 1985 Sat | | Pittsburgh | NY Islanders | Rissling-Dineen
Hillier-Sutter (3) |
| Feb 16, 1985 Sat | | Hartford | NY Islanders | Neufeld-Lane (5)
Robertson-Sutter (2) |
| Feb 17, 1985 Sun | | NY Islanders | NY Rangers | Brawl at 39:25 (4)
Trottier-Patrick (1.5)
Gillies-Richmond (1.6)
Hrudey-Vanbiesbrouck (5.3)
Sutter-Sandstrom |
| Feb 19, 1985 Tue | | Calgary | NY Islanders | Konroyd-Sutter
Sheehy-Nystrom (5) |
| Feb 21, 1985 Thu | | Winnipeg | NY Islanders | Turnbull-Sutter
Watters-Sutter |
| Feb 23, 1985 Sat | | Boston | NY Islanders | Blum-Flatley
Blum-Gillies (4)
Blum-Sutter (5) |
| Feb 24, 1985 Sun | | NY Islanders | Montreal | Add Fight |
| Feb 27, 1985 Wed | | NY Islanders | Calgary | Sutter-Hunter
Sutter-Risebrough
Gilbert-Eloranta |
| Mar 2, 1985 Sat | | NY Islanders | Toronto | Dineen-Leeman (5)
Henry-McGill (5) |
| Mar 3, 1985 Sun | | NY Islanders | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Mar 5, 1985 Tue | | Philadelphia | NY Islanders | Sutter-Langevin
Tocchet-Diduck
Poulin-Boutilier |
| Mar 7, 1985 Thu | | NY Islanders | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Mar 9, 1985 Sat | | Toronto | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Mar 12, 1985 Tue | | NY Islanders | St. Louis | (Rough) Sutter-Johnson
Kortko-Dufour (4)
Henry-Dufour (1) |
| Mar 13, 1985 Wed | | NY Islanders | Chicago | Dineen-Frawley |
| Mar 16, 1985 Sat | | Washington | NY Islanders | Andersson-Sutter
Carpenter-Sutter
(Rough) Stevens-Bossy
Scrum at 46:25 |
| Mar 17, 1985 Sun | | NY Islanders | Philadelphia | Flatley-Marsh
Sutter-Marsh (4) |
| Mar 19, 1985 Tue | | Los Angeles | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Mar 21, 1985 Thu | | Quebec | NY Islanders | Cote-Sutter
(Rough) Stastny-Smith |
| Mar 24, 1985 Sun | | NY Islanders | NY Rangers | Dineen-Fotiu
Mini-Brawl at 51:21
Kerr-Maloney |
| Mar 26, 1985 Tue | | Edmonton | NY Islanders | Jackson-Diduck (7)
McClelland-Lane (5.5)
Hunter-Nystrom (4) |
| Mar 28, 1985 Thu | | NY Islanders | Quebec | Add Fight |
| Mar 30, 1985 Sat | | NY Islanders | Washington | Flatley-Adams |
| Apr 2, 1985 Tue | | Pittsburgh | NY Islanders | Young-Henry |
| Apr 4, 1985 Thu | | NY Islanders | Philadelphia | Sutter-Smith (4) |
| Apr 6, 1985 Sat | | New Jersey | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Apr 10, 1985 Wed | Round 1 | Game 1 | NY Islanders | Washington | Add Fight |
| Apr 11, 1985 Thu | Round 1 | Game 2 | NY Islanders | Washington | Add Fight |
| Apr 13, 1985 Sat | Round 1 | Game 3 | Washington | NY Islanders | (Cheap) Duchesne-Bourne
(Rough) Stevens-Sutter
(Rough) Stevens-Boutilier
Adams-Sutter |
| Apr 14, 1985 Sun | Round 1 | Game 4 | Washington | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Apr 16, 1985 Tue | Round 1 | Game 5 | NY Islanders | Washington | (Rough) Sutter-Langway
(Rough) Smith-Gartner (7)
(Rough) Boutilier-Adams
Dineen-Duchesne
Morrow-Franceschetti |
| Apr 18, 1985 Thu | QF | Game 1 | NY Islanders | Philadelphia | (Cheap) unknown-McCrimmon
Sutter-Crossman (3)
Brawl at 59:21
(Rough) Gillies-Brown (3)
(Refused) Nystrom-Brown
Dineen-Paterson (4.7) |
| Apr 21, 1985 Sun | QF | Game 2 | NY Islanders | Philadelphia | Mini-Brawl at 21:57 |
| Apr 23, 1985 Tue | QF | Game 3 | Philadelphia | NY Islanders | (Rough) Crossman-Kortko
(Rough) Sutter-Jonsson
Paterson-Sutter (2.5)
Tocchet-Sutter (3.5)
Carson-Kortko (1)
Hospodar-Gillies (2.5) |
| Apr 25, 1985 Thu | QF | Game 4 | Philadelphia | NY Islanders | Marsh-Sutter
(Rough) Paterson-Potvin
Scrum at 56:24
Hospodar-Nystrom (4.6) |
| Apr 28, 1985 Sun | QF | Game 5 | NY Islanders | Philadelphia | Add Fight |