| Sep 15, 1983 Thu | Preseason | Buffalo | Montreal | Langevin-Tremblay |
| Sep 16, 1983 Fri | Preseason | Quebec | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Sep 17, 1983 Sat | Preseason | NY Islanders | Buffalo | Gillies-Foligno
Hallin-Ruff |
| Sep 18, 1983 Sun | Preseason | Boston | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Sep 20, 1983 Tue | Preseason | Buffalo | NY Islanders | (Rough) Hamel-Lane |
| Sep 21, 1983 Wed | Preseason | Buffalo | Toronto | Add Fight |
| Sep 24, 1983 Sat | Preseason | Buffalo | Quebec | (Rough) McKenna-Hunter
(Cheap) Unknown-Wesley |
| Sep 25, 1983 Sun | Preseason | Toronto | Buffalo | McRae-Fenyves (4)
Korn-Foligno |
| Sep 28, 1983 Wed | Preseason | Boston | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Sep 30, 1983 Fri | Preseason | Montreal | Buffalo | Carlson-Foligno |
| Oct 5, 1983 Wed | | Hartford | Buffalo | Hospodar-Cyr |
| Oct 8, 1983 Sat | | Buffalo | Quebec | Add Fight |
| Oct 9, 1983 Sun | | Washington | Buffalo | Brawl at 46:43
Adams-Playfair
Shand-McKenna |
| Oct 12, 1983 Wed | | Buffalo | Toronto | Cloutier-Daoust |
| Oct 15, 1983 Sat | | Buffalo | Boston | Playfair-Kluzak (3) |
| Oct 16, 1983 Sun | | NY Islanders | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Oct 18, 1983 Tue | | Buffalo | Pittsburgh | Add Fight |
| Oct 22, 1983 Sat | | Buffalo | Hartford | Add Fight |
| Oct 23, 1983 Sun | | Winnipeg | Buffalo | Campbell-Hamel |
| Oct 26, 1983 Wed | | Buffalo | Detroit | Add Fight |
| Oct 28, 1983 Fri | | Los Angeles | Buffalo | Nicholls-Housley |
| Oct 30, 1983 Sun | | Montreal | Buffalo | Nilan-Wiemer
Carlson-Foligno
Hamel-Ruff |
| Nov 2, 1983 Wed | | NY Rangers | Buffalo | Osborne-Hamel
Scrum at 42:32 |
| Nov 5, 1983 Sat | | Buffalo | NY Islanders | Add Fight |
| Nov 6, 1983 Sun | | Quebec | Buffalo | (Rough) Hunter-Ruff
(Rough) Stastny-Foligno
Wesley-Ruff |
| Nov 9, 1983 Wed | | Boston | Buffalo | Brawl at 32:31
Milbury-Ramsey
O'Reilly-Playfair (5.3)
Mini-Brawl at 34:15
Silk-Hamel (6) |
| Nov 11, 1983 Fri | | Toronto | Buffalo | Farrish-Ruff
Vaive-Ramsey |
| Nov 13, 1983 Sun | | Calgary | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Nov 16, 1983 Wed | | Buffalo | Winnipeg | Add Fight |
| Nov 18, 1983 Fri | | Buffalo | Edmonton | Playfair-Lumley
Brawl at 32:32 |
| Nov 19, 1983 Sat | | Buffalo | Calgary | Foligno-Hanson (1)
Korab-Konroyd (1) |
| Nov 23, 1983 Wed | | Buffalo | NY Rangers | Ruff-Greschner (7) |
| Nov 25, 1983 Fri | | Chicago | Buffalo | O'Callahan-Moller |
| Nov 26, 1983 Sat | | Buffalo | Quebec | McKenna-Hunter |
| Nov 29, 1983 Tue | | Buffalo | Montreal | Seiling-Hamel (2)
(Rough) Moller-Sevigny |
| Dec 2, 1983 Fri | | St. Louis | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Dec 4, 1983 Sun | | Montreal | Buffalo | Nilan-Wiemer
Tremblay-Ramsey (7) |
| Dec 6, 1983 Tue | | Buffalo | St. Louis | Ruff-Anderson
Playfair-Turnbull
Ruff-Dore
Foligno-Schofield |
| Dec 7, 1983 Wed | | Buffalo | Chicago | Cyr-Murray |
| Dec 10, 1983 Sat | | Buffalo | Boston | McKenna-Milbury (5.3) |
| Dec 11, 1983 Sun | | Buffalo | Philadelphia | (Rough) Playfair-Sutter
(Rough) Foligno-Kerr
Fenyves-Allison |
| Dec 14, 1983 Wed | | New Jersey | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Dec 17, 1983 Sat | | Buffalo | Hartford | Hamel-Crombeen |
| Dec 18, 1983 Sun | | Vancouver | Buffalo | McCarthy-McKenna |
| Dec 21, 1983 Wed | | Hartford | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Dec 26, 1983 Mon | | Boston | Buffalo | O'Reilly-Korab
Bourque-Cyr (5.7) |
| Dec 27, 1983 Tue | | Buffalo | Montreal | Playfair-Nilan (7)
Playfair-Nilan
(Rough) Barrasso-Lemieux
Scrum at 57:26 (5) |
| Dec 29, 1983 Thu | | Quebec | Buffalo | Hunter-Ruff
Moller-Ramsay
Hunter-Peterson |
| Dec 31, 1983 Sat | | NY Rangers | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Jan 4, 1984 Wed | | Winnipeg | Buffalo | Lukowich-Ruff |
| Jan 7, 1984 Sat | | Buffalo | Washington | Add Fight |
| Jan 8, 1984 Sun | | Montreal | Buffalo | Turnbull-Korab |
| Jan 11, 1984 Wed | | Philadelphia | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Jan 13, 1984 Fri | | Edmonton | Buffalo | (Cheap) Anderson-unknown
(Rough) Coffey-Ramsey |
| Jan 14, 1984 Sat | | Buffalo | Detroit | Ruff-Lambert |
| Jan 17, 1984 Tue | | Buffalo | Vancouver | Add Fight |
| Jan 18, 1984 Wed | | Buffalo | Los Angeles | Add Fight |
| Jan 21, 1984 Sat | | Buffalo | St. Louis | Cyr-Sutter |
| Jan 23, 1984 Mon | | Buffalo | Boston | Foligno-Dufour (8) |
| Jan 25, 1984 Wed | | Washington | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Jan 27, 1984 Fri | | Detroit | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Jan 29, 1984 Sun | | Pittsburgh | Buffalo | (Rough) Boutette-Playfair
Rissling-Playfair |
| Feb 2, 1984 Thu | | Buffalo | Boston | Add Fight |
| Feb 3, 1984 Fri | | Minnesota | Buffalo | Plett-Playfair
MacAdam-Cyr
Mini-Brawl at 43:23
Roberts-Cyr |
| Feb 5, 1984 Sun | | Quebec | Buffalo | Hunter-Andreychuk |
| Feb 8, 1984 Wed | | Buffalo | Pittsburgh | Foligno-McSorley (2)
Playfair-Rissling (4.5) |
| Feb 9, 1984 Thu | | New Jersey | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Feb 11, 1984 Sat | | Buffalo | Montreal | Add Fight |
| Feb 15, 1984 Wed | | Boston | Buffalo | Markwart-Foligno (8)
Kluzak-Playfair (5.8) |
| Feb 17, 1984 Fri | | Minnesota | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Feb 19, 1984 Sun | | Hartford | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Feb 21, 1984 Tue | | Buffalo | Philadelphia | Add Fight |
| Feb 23, 1984 Thu | | Buffalo | Hartford | Add Fight |
| Feb 25, 1984 Sat | | Buffalo | Minnesota | Add Fight |
| Feb 27, 1984 Mon | | Boston | Buffalo | (Rough) Markwart-Playfair |
| Feb 29, 1984 Wed | | Buffalo | Chicago | Add Fight |
| Mar 3, 1984 Sat | | Buffalo | Quebec | Ruff-Moller |
| Mar 4, 1984 Sun | | Quebec | Buffalo | McKegney-Foligno (5)
(Cheap) Hunter-Ramsey
Mini-Brawl at 63:56 (4)
Price-Seiling |
| Mar 6, 1984 Tue | | Buffalo | Montreal | Playfair-Nilan
Playfair-Nilan (6.3) |
| Mar 9, 1984 Fri | | Los Angeles | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Mar 11, 1984 Sun | | Hartford | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Mar 14, 1984 Wed | | Buffalo | Calgary | Peterson-Risebrough |
| Mar 17, 1984 Sat | | Buffalo | Vancouver | Ruff-Neely (7) |
| Mar 18, 1984 Sun | | Buffalo | Edmonton | Add Fight |
| Mar 21, 1984 Wed | | Montreal | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Mar 24, 1984 Sat | | Buffalo | New Jersey | Add Fight |
| Mar 25, 1984 Sun | | NY Islanders | Buffalo | Add Fight |
| Mar 27, 1984 Tue | | Buffalo | Hartford | Playfair-Robertson (5.2) |
| Mar 31, 1984 Sat | | Buffalo | Quebec | Foligno-Hunter
Korab-Hunter
(Rough) Ruff-Price
Korab-Mann
Brawl at 53:54
Playfair-Cote (3) |
| Apr 1, 1984 Sun | | Toronto | Buffalo | Gavin-Ramsey |
| Apr 4, 1984 Wed | Round 1 | Game 1 | Quebec | Buffalo | (Hit) Mann-Ruff (5)
Stastny-Foligno |
| Apr 5, 1984 Thu | Round 1 | Game 2 | Quebec | Buffalo | Cote-Foligno
Scrum at 36:28
Paiement-Ruff (5)
Mini-Brawl at 55:35
Hunter-Barrasso |
| Apr 7, 1984 Sat | Round 1 | Game 3 | Buffalo | Quebec | Mini-Brawl at 15:27
Foligno-Hunter
Korab-Wesley
Foligno-Moller
Fenyves-Wesley (3) |