| Rank | League | Fight |
| 1 | NHL | May 21, 1978 Pierre Bouchard (Montreal) vs. Stan Jonathan (Boston) at 6:28 |
| 2 | NHL | Sep 15, 1997 Nick Kypreos (Toronto) vs. Ryan VandenBussche (NY Rangers) at 2:10 |
| 3 | NHL | Nov 19, 1999 Ryan VandenBussche (Chicago) vs. Stu Grimson (Anaheim) at 46:15 |
| 4 | NHL | Jan 21, 1998 Michel Petit (Phoenix) vs. Scott Walker (Vancouver) at 8:19 |
| 5 | NHL | Mar 3, 2000 Kyle Freadrich (Tampa Bay) vs. Ryan VandenBussche (Chicago) at 3:27 |
| 6 | NHL | Jan 15, 2001 Jiri Fischer (Detroit) vs. Scott Thornton (San Jose) at 35:40 |
| 7 | NHL | Dec 16, 2001 Sean Brown (Edmonton) vs. Todd Fedoruk (Philadelphia) at 6:53 |
| 8 | QMJHL | Feb 6, 1994 Georges Laraque (St-Jean) vs. Sylvain Blouin (Laval) at 26:29 |
| 9 | ECHL | Mar 13, 1999 Trevor Senn (Richmond) vs. Ken Tasker (Toledo) at 1:52 |
| 10 | NHL | Dec 3, 2000 Todd Harvey (San Jose) vs. Jason Smith (Edmonton) at 23:29 |
| 11 | OHL | Sep 15, 2006 Richard Greenop (Windsor) vs. Tomas Sample (Sarnia) |
| 12 | NHL | Oct 25, 1989 Darin Kimble (Quebec) vs. Marc Laforge (Hartford) |
| 13 | NHL | Oct 10, 1993 Jeff Odgers (San Jose) vs. Warren Rychel (Los Angeles) at 59:49 |
| 14 | NHL | Mar 13, 1998 Brent Severyn (Anaheim) vs. Darryl Sydor (Dallas) at 56:52 |
| 15 | LNAH | Nov 17, 2006 Joel Theriault (Saint-Georges) vs. Jon "Nasty" Mirasty (Sorel-Tracy) at 0:09 |
| 16 | NHL | Sep 24, 1983 Curt Fraser (Chicago) vs. Bobby Smith (Minnesota) at 57:13 |
| 17 | NHL | Oct 3, 1997 Alex Hicks (Pittsburgh) vs. Nelson Emerson (Carolina) at 15:49 |
| 18 | QMJHL | Mar 26, 2005 Erick Lizon (Victoriaville) vs. Brandon Tidball (Quebec) at 39:50 |
| 19 | EIHL | Sep 11, 2005 Calle Carlsson (Nottingham) vs. Paul Sample (Sheffield) |
| 20 | LNAH | Jan 26, 2007 Thomas Bellemare (Thetford Mines) vs. Joel Theriault (Saint-Georges) at 1:18 |
| 21 | OHL | Oct 11, 2008 Kyle DeCoste (Brampton) vs. Eric O'Dell (Sudbury) at 59:52 |
| 22 | EIHL | Sep 7, 2008 Rick Kozak (Hull) vs. Marc Levers (Nottingham) at 9:23 |
| 23 | EIHL | Dec 26, 2009 Jason Hewitt (Sheffield) vs. Bruce Richardson (Nottingham) at 4:57 |
| 24 | NHL | Feb 14, 1982 Doug Smith (Los Angeles) vs. Darryl Sittler (Philadelphia) at 47:48 |
| 25 | NHL | Feb 16, 2004 Jeremy Stevenson (Nashville) vs. David Ling (Columbus) at 3:21 |
| 26 | NHL | Oct 8, 2005 Dan Hinote (Colorado) vs. Jason Arnott (Dallas) at 53:12 |
| 27 | OHL | Oct 9, 2006 Corey Syvret (London) vs. Jordan Nolan (Windsor) at 36:58 |
| 28 | QMJHL | Oct 14, 2007 Jean-Simon Legros (Acadie-Bathurst) vs. Brett Gallant (Saint John) at 1:43 |
| 29 | AHL | Jan 24, 2009 Joe Piskula (Manchester) vs. Jay Beagle (Hershey) at 10:54 |
| 30 | NHL | Dec 19, 1979 Larry Playfair (Buffalo) vs. Jimmy Mann (Winnipeg) at 24:32 |
| 31 | NHL | Dec 19, 1981 Wilf Paiement (Toronto) vs. Barry Legge (Winnipeg) at 53:46 |
| 32 | NHL | Apr 9, 1983 Dave Semenko (Edmonton) vs. Bryan Maxwell (Winnipeg) at 32:19 |
| 33 | WHL | Jan 2, 1998 Robyn Regehr (Kamloops) vs. Scott Parker (Kelowna) at 30:51 |
| 34 | OJHL | Nov 11, 2007 Paul McMullen (Markham) vs. Nick Ciampini (St. Michael's) at 59:58 |
| 35 | LNAH | Apr 10, 2009 Derek Parker (Trois-Rivieres) vs. Curtis Tidball (Pont-Rouge) at 59:25 |
| 36 | OHL | Mar 8, 2009 Mike Yovanic (London) vs. Adam Wallace (Windsor) at 6:20 |
| 37 | OHL | Dec 19, 2009 Ryan Lopes (Mississauga) vs. Tyler Hostetter (Erie) at 56:39 |
| 38 | NHL | Jan 25, 1951 Bill Ezinicki (Boston) vs. Ted Lindsay (Detroit) |
| 39 | NHL | Apr 13, 1968 Noel Picard (St. Louis) vs. Claude LaForge (Philadelphia) at 49:13 |
| 40 | QMJHL | Dec 30, 2002 Sebastien Nolet (Rimouski) vs. Michael Forbes (Quebec) at 59:13 |
| 41 | OHL | Feb 15, 2003 Brandon Prust (London) vs. David Herring (Erie) at 2:35 |
| 42 | CHL | Mar 6, 2004 Alan Nolan (Laredo) vs. Shawn Scanzano (Tulsa) at 7:41 |
| 43 | OHL | Oct 25, 2006 Derek Joslin (Ottawa) vs. Andrew Gibbons (Belleville) at 40:00 |
| 44 | OJHL | Oct 13, 2007 Derek Foote (Durham) vs. Shane Ferguson (Dixie) at 55:19 |
| 45 | LNAH | Sep 23, 2007 Hugo Poulin (Thetford Mines) vs. Matthew Lemire (Trois-Rivieres) at 46:24 |
| 46 | GOJHL | Dec 5, 2008 Jared Anger (Strathroy) vs. Eric Millisor (Stratford) at 51:27 |
| 47 | CHL | Apr 4, 2009 Steve Weidlich (Laredo) vs. Dave Van Drunen (Odessa) at 60:00 |
| 48 | AAHA | Oct 16, 2009 Jerry Cardinale (Chicago) vs. Brandon Holmes (Madison) at 44:20 |
| 49 | CSHL | Jan 22, 2010 Devin Holmes (Quad City) vs. Timothy Prinz (Peoria) at 14:55 |
| 50 | NHL | Nov 27, 1946 Bill Ezinicki (Toronto) vs. Leo Reise (Chicago) |